Property Chapter 3 Part 4B

Part 4B: Earthquake Insurance

Private Market Coverage for Seismic Activity

Start Here: 5 Things You MUST Know

1

Earthquake Insurance is PRIVATE (Not a Government Program!)

Unlike flood insurance (which comes from the federal government through NFIP), earthquake insurance is sold by regular private insurance companies like State Farm, Allstate, etc. There's no federal earthquake program. In California, there's the CEA (California Earthquake Authority) - a special organization, but it's still not the government.

2

Deductibles Are PERCENTAGES, Not Dollar Amounts (10-25%!)

Your homeowner's policy might have a $1,000 deductible. Earthquake insurance is DIFFERENT - it uses percentages of your home's value! If you have a 15% deductible on a $400,000 home, that's $60,000 you pay before insurance kicks in! This shocks many homeowners after an earthquake.

3

Earthquake Coverage is NEVER Required

Remember how flood insurance is mandatory if you live in a high-risk flood zone (SFHA = Special Flood Hazard Area) and have a federally-backed mortgage? Earthquake is different - it's ALWAYS optional. Even in California where earthquakes are common, no law or lender forces you to buy earthquake coverage.

4

"Fire Following Earthquake" is Covered by Your REGULAR Homeowner's Policy!

Here's a key exam point: If an earthquake breaks a gas line and your house catches fire, your normal homeowner's insurance pays for the fire damage - you don't need earthquake insurance for that! Earthquake insurance only covers the shaking damage (cracks, collapsed walls, foundation damage). Fire is covered under your standard fire coverage.

5

Two Ways to Get Coverage: Endorsement OR DIC Policy

Endorsement = You add earthquake coverage to your existing homeowner's policy (like adding an option to your phone plan). DIC Policy (Difference in Conditions) = A separate, standalone policy that fills gaps in your regular insurance, including earthquake coverage. Both work - it's just different ways to buy the coverage.

1. Earthquake Coverage Basics

Definition

Earthquake = A trembling or shaking of the earth that is volcanic or seismic in origin, often resulting in severe damage.

Seismic Origin

Tectonic plate movement (most common)

Volcanic Origin

Earthquakes from volcanic activity

Why Excluded from Standard Policies?

  • Excluded from most standard property forms
  • • Catastrophic, concentrated losses in specific geographic areas
  • • Available as endorsement to property policy
  • • May be written in a Difference in Conditions (DIC) Policy
  • NEVER mandatory - always optional

What Earthquake Insurance Covers

Building Damage

Structural damage from shaking

Personal Property

Contents damaged by earthquake

Loss of Use

Additional living expenses (unlike NFIP!)

Foundation Damage

Cracks and structural foundation issues

What's NOT Covered

Flood from earthquake (tsunami, dam break)
Land and land values
Vehicles
External masonry veneer (often excluded)

What is "External Masonry Veneer"?

Masonry veneer is a thin layer of brick, stone, or stucco attached to the OUTSIDE of a building for decoration. It's NOT structural - it's just a "skin" that makes the house look nice.

Example: Your house has wooden walls, but the outside is covered with a layer of decorative brick. During an earthquake, that brick facing cracks and falls off. Many earthquake policies WON'T pay to repair it because it's just decorative, not structural. You'd need to check if your specific policy covers it or excludes it.

2. Percentage Deductibles

The BIG Difference

Unlike standard property policies with dollar deductibles ($500, $1,000), earthquake uses PERCENTAGE deductibles ranging from 10% to 25% of coverage limit.

Deductible Calculations

$300,000 coverage × 15% = $45,000
$400,000 coverage × 15% = $60,000
$500,000 coverage × 25% = $125,000

Why Such High Deductibles?

  • Catastrophic nature of earthquake losses
  • • Keeps premiums affordable
  • • Encourages loss prevention and mitigation
  • • Shares risk between insurer and insured

Real-World Scenario: Percentage Shock

The Setup: Nina has a $400,000 home. Her homeowners policy has a $2,000 deductible. She adds earthquake coverage with a 15% deductible.

What Happens: An earthquake causes $100,000 in damage.

The Result: Nina's earthquake deductible is $60,000 (15% of $400,000)! The policy pays only $40,000. She thought it would be like her homeowners $2,000 deductible - she was SHOCKED to pay $60,000 out of pocket.

3. California Earthquake Authority (CEA)

What is CEA?

  • Publicly managed, privately funded organization
  • • Created after the 1994 Northridge earthquake
  • • Provides residential earthquake coverage in California
  • • Not a government agency - operates like private insurer

CEA Coverage Types

Dwelling

Based on replacement cost

Personal Property

$5,000 - $200,000

Loss of Use

$1,500 - $100,000

CEA Deductible Options

5%

Minimum

10%

Common

15%

Standard

25%

Maximum

Higher deductible = Lower premium

Real-World Scenario: CEA Choice

The Setup: Patricia owns a $600,000 home in Los Angeles. She's choosing between CEA deductibles: 5% ($30,000) or 25% ($150,000).

What Happens: 5% option costs $1,800/year. 25% option costs $600/year - $1,200 annual savings.

The Result: Patricia chooses 25% to save money. She saves $1,200/year but accepts risk of paying first $150,000 if a major quake hits.

4. Fire Following Earthquake

Critical Distinction!

Standard property policies DO cover fire damage that occurs following an earthquake, even though earthquake itself is excluded!

Standard Property Policy Covers:

  • • Fire damage from earthquake
  • • Explosion damage
  • • Smoke damage from fire

Earthquake Policy Covers:

  • • Shake damage to structure
  • • Foundation damage
  • • Crack damage from tremors

Scenario: Fire After Earthquake

The Setup: Marcus has only a homeowners policy (no earthquake coverage). An earthquake cracks his foundation and breaks a gas line.

What Happens: The gas line ignites, causing fire that destroys the house.

The Result: Homeowners policy pays for fire damage ($400,000). Foundation cracks are NOT covered (earthquake exclusion). But the fire damage IS covered!

Scenario: Both Policies Apply

The Setup: Elena has homeowners AND earthquake coverage. Earthquake causes $80,000 structural damage and starts a fire causing $200,000 more damage.

What Happens: She files claims with both insurers.

The Result: Homeowners pays $200,000 (fire). Earthquake policy pays $80,000 minus percentage deductible. Total coverage across both policies!

5. Flood vs Earthquake Comparison

Feature Flood (NFIP) Earthquake
Federal Program Yes (FEMA) No (Private)
Mandatory Purchase In SFHA with federal mortgage NEVER mandatory
Waiting Period 30 days (standard) Varies by insurer
Deductible Type Dollar amount PERCENTAGE (10-25%)
Living Expenses (ALE) NOT covered Usually covered
Standardized Coverage Yes - all WYO identical No - varies by insurer
Rates Set By FEMA Each insurer

Key Takeaway

  • Flood = Federal, standardized, can be mandatory
  • Earthquake = Private, varies by insurer, ALWAYS optional
  • Both excluded from standard property policies
  • Fire following earthquake = Standard policy covers it!

Cheat Sheet

Print for quick reference

Definition

Trembling/shaking from volcanic or seismic origin

Deductibles

PERCENTAGE: 10-25%

CEA: 5%, 10%, 15%, 25%

Coverage Options

Endorsement to policy

OR DIC Policy

Fire Following

STANDARD policy covers fire!

No earthquake policy needed

CEA (California)

Created after 1994 Northridge

Publicly managed, privately funded

Key Facts

NEVER mandatory

Private market (not federal)

Exam Trap Alerts

1. Percentage, NOT Dollar Deductible

15% of $400,000 = $60,000. Not $500! This shocks many policyholders.

2. Fire Following = Standard Policy

Fire damage from earthquake IS covered by standard property policy. Shake damage is NOT.

3. NEVER Mandatory

Unlike flood (mandatory in SFHA), earthquake is ALWAYS optional.

4. CEA Minimum = 5%

California Earthquake Authority starts at 5%, not 10%. Know all four: 5%, 10%, 15%, 25%.

5. Private Market, Not Federal

Earthquake = private insurers. Flood = federal NFIP. Don't confuse them!

6. DIC Policy Option

Earthquake can be endorsement OR Difference in Conditions policy. Know both options.

7. Earthquake Covers ALE

Unlike NFIP (no ALE), earthquake insurance usually covers additional living expenses.

Quick Reference Summary

Private Market

Not federal like NFIP

10-25% Deductible

Percentage, not dollars

CEA: 5-25%

California options

Never Mandatory

Always optional

Fire Following

Standard policy covers!

Endorsement or DIC

Two coverage options

ALE Covered

Unlike NFIP!

Varies by Insurer

Not standardized